Comparing Experimental and Theoretical Probability
Probability can be found in two different ways: using theoretical probability and using experimental probability. Comparing these helps judge how reliable results are and whether a theoretical model is appropriate.
Theoretical Probability
Theoretical probability is calculated using reasoning when all outcomes are equally likely.
It is found using:
\( \frac{number\ of\ favourable\ outcomes}{total\ number\ of\ possible\ outcomes} \)
Theoretical probability:
• is based on assumptions about fairness
• does not use experimental data
• gives an exact value
It represents what is expected to happen in the long term if the experiment is fair.
Experimental Probability
Experimental probability is estimated from actual results.
It is calculated using relative frequency:
\( \frac{number\ of\ times\ the\ event\ occurs}{total\ number\ of\ trials} \)
Experimental probability:
• is based on observed data
• can change as more trials are carried out
• gives an estimate, not an exact value
Small numbers of trials often give unreliable estimates.
Comparing the Two Probabilities
To compare probabilities:
• calculate the theoretical probability
• calculate the experimental probability
• compare the two values
If the experimental probability is close to the theoretical probability, this suggests:
• the experiment is fair
• the model is reasonable
If the values are quite different, this may suggest:
• too few trials were carried out
• the experiment is biased
• outcomes are not equally likely
Experimental results are expected to vary, especially with small samples
Effect of Number of Trials
As the number of trials increases:
• experimental probability usually gets closer to theoretical probability
• random variation has less effect
This explains why repeated trials give more reliable results.
With very few trials, large differences are normal and expected.
Interpreting Differences
Differences between experimental and theoretical probability should be explained carefully.
Possible reasons include:
• chance variation
• experimental error
• bias in the experiment
Differences do not automatically mean the theoretical probability is wrong.
Drawing Conclusions
When drawing conclusions:
• state both probabilities clearly
• comment on how close they are
• consider the number of trials
• avoid claiming exact agreement
Conclusions should be cautious and evidence based.
Key Points to Remember
Theoretical probability is calculated using equally likely outcomes.
Experimental probability is estimated from results.
Experimental probability can vary from trial to trial.
Larger numbers of trials usually give closer agreement.
Differences should be explained, not ignored.
Comparing experimental and theoretical probability helps link mathematical models with real world evidence and supports sensible conclusions about chance and fairness.